Pages Navigation Menu
Categories Navigation Menu

New York’s Tastiest Turkey Sandwiches

Roast Turkey Club Sandwich with Cranberry Sauce 500 2746Turkey doesn’t tend to get a whole lot of love beyond the Thanksgiving table except when it comes to sandwiches — and even those can be snooze-worthy affairs. Which is why, in the days leading up to the holiday, we thought we’d round up a few, awesome between-the-bread creations, that actually shine an ultra-flattering spotlight on the oft-maligned bird — from the Asian-inspired Pulled Turkey at Num Pang, to Parm’s Spicy Roast Turkey & Mozzarella to No. 7 Sub’s Turkey & Frito Combo…

No. 7 Sub

No. 7 Sub
16 W 29th Street
Midtown West,New York 10010
(212) 679-1939

Tyler Kord’s wonky No. 7 Sub would never deign to serve anything so pedestrian as plain old tuna fish or ham and cheese. Which is why you’ll find tricked out turkey selections, such as The Frito Kid 2, which pairs the freshly roast & sliced poultry with black bean hummus, pickled jalapenos and yes — twisty, salty Fritos.  Yum!

Read More

Parm

Parm
248 Mulberry Stret
Nolita,New York 10012
(212) 993-7189

It’s hard to keep up with the force that is the Major Food Group as they roll out restaurant after restaurant, most recently opening Sadelle’s and Santina.  While the media focuses on their shiny, new spots, we’re still digging on the very casual, Italian-American Parm with now famous pizza knots, eggplant parm platter and ice cream cakes.  Lest we forget their uber popular Turkey Sandwich, made with honey-glazed turkey, spicy sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and homemade mozzarella. 

Read More

 

Court Street Grocers

Court Street Grocers
485 Court Street
Brooklyn,New York 11231
(718) 722-7229

In addition to brand new menu additions at their Manhattan spot, such as the Dirty Turkey (roasted turkey, chopped liver and chow-chow), Court Street Grocers has long demonstrated a surprising affinity for the other, other white meat.  Look no further than their  Turkey Reuben (slathered in sauerkraut and comeback sauce), the Turkey & Durkee (paved with sweet pickles and durkee sauce), and the Turkey Club; a triple decker assemblage of confit dark meat, Edward’s bacon and lettuce.

Read More

Num Pang

Num Pang
140 E 41st St
Midtown East,New York 10017
(212) 867-8889

In addition to staples like Hoisin Meatballs and Peppercorn Catfish, this cluster of fast-casual Cambodian sandwich shops are offering a decidedly seasonal selection — the tender Pulled Turkey — anointed with jewel-like smatterings of tangy, pickled cranberries.

Read More

City Subs

City Subs
82 5th Ave
Park Slope,New York 11217
(718) 636-1777

Brooklyn has happily heralded the return of this beloved sammy shop, which closed its Park Slope doors for one exceedingly long year.  Decked out with a selection of 29 composed sandwiches (although you’re more than welcome to construct your own), the menu has proved as impressive as ever, featuring the “Baltic Street” with peppercorn turkey and monterey jack, the “Degraw Street” with smoked turkey, smoked ham and smoked gouda, and the toasty “Fourth Avenue,” a choice of any turkey topped with bacon and melted swiss cheese.

Read More

Shopsin’s

Shopsin’s
120 Essex St
Lower East Side,New York 10002

Once your eyes adjust to the untamed jumble that is the inimitable Shopsin’s menu, you’ll find that turkey appears year round, in a number of funky guises — think a pressed Monte Cristo (turkey, ham, swiss and strawberry jam, on eggy french toast), the High School (a hot turkey sandwich ladled with gravy and sausage stuffing), and the Savannah; a self-described “mushroom gumbo turkey mountain.”

Read More

Morgan’s

Morgan’s
267 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn,New York 11217
(718) 622-2224

The Brooklyn-based Morgan’s has managed to stand out from New York’s estimable barbecue crowd by offering a mean, pit-smoked turkey, moist strips of which can be enjoyed as a sloppy sandwich, topped with sauce and crunchy coleslaw in a Martin’s potato roll.

Read More

Angela’s Sandwich Shop

Angela’s Sandwich Shop
1428 6th Ave
Midtown West,New York 10019
(212) 759-5344

Angela’s has long been a saving grace for Midtown’s hungry office workers, specializing in affordable, over-stuffed sandwiches, and the Thanksgiving Dinner is one of our all-time favorites.  It comes piled high with grilled fresh turkey breast, cheddar cheese and cornbread stuffing, then moistened with rich gravy and sweet, gelled cranberry sauce.

Read More

 

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *