Pages Navigation Menu
Categories Navigation Menu

NYC's Best Whoopie Pies

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for WannaHavaCookie_Assorted_Whoopie_Pies.jpg

I’m a little sick of cupcakes.  The idea of mini-frosted cakes, but cupcakes require patience.  First, you’ve got to to peel off the baking cup, then come up with a strategy to maximize the cake-to-frosting ratio of every bite.  Ultimately, it ends in sticky fingers or unequal bites.  Which is I’m thrilled the whoopie pie is making a big comeback.  The whoopie pie is pretty much a hybrid of desserts — a cupcake, a cookie, and a cake.   New York Times writer, Michele Maynard, recently wrote, “The closest description may be a cake-like sandwich or sandwich-like cake.”   Here’s a rundown of our New York City favorites…

One Girl Cookies
68 Dean St. (btwn. Boerum Pl. & Smith St.)
(212) 675-4996
There’s so many charming things about this Brooklyn Bakery — the family photos on the boxes, the family-named desserts, the way the owner and baker met.   (Dave was looking for an apartment and a baking job.”  Dawn was looking for a roommate and a baker.)  Lucky for us, he opted for the job baking at One Girl Cookies.  His unique take on is a pumpkin whoopie pie filled with rich cream cheese filling.    

Marisa Angebranndt’s serious about her whoopie pies (pictured above.)  I discovered Wannahavacookie at Brownstoner’s Brooklyn Flea, but you can order her sweets online.  Wannahavacookie offers everything from red
velvet to chocolate mint to chocolate chocolate.  My favorite is the chocolate with a salty peanut butter filling.   

Thumbnail image for whoopietrio.jpg
359 Van Brunt St. (btwn. Dikeman & Sullivan Sts.)
Brooklyn, NY

(718) 222-0345

Baked excels at so many different desserts it’s hard to pick between all of them, and even harder to choose between the roster of whoopie pies (pictured right.)  Seasonal flavors include chocolate, peanut butter, lemon, strawberry, and pistachio. They change daily, so you’ll never tire of their flavors. 

Joyce Bakeshop
646 Vanderbilt Ave. (btwn. Park Pl. & Prospect Pl.)
Brooklyn, NY

(718) 623-7470
This shop bakes all of the classics — madeleines, financiers and an all-American whoopie pie. Their version is a chocolate whoopie pie with silky smooth marshmallow filling.

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Whoopie_Cookie.JPG
Magnolia Bakery
401 Bleecker St., at W 11th St.
(212) 462-2572 
You don’t have to be a cupcake connoisseur to know Magnolia Bakery and its worshippers.  As Magnolia continues to expand its empire, it’s also expanding its menu to include a “whoopie cookie” — maple cream cheese filling sandwiched between brown sugar cookies. 

Trois Pommes Patisserie
260 5th Ave. (btwn. 1st St. & Carroll St.)
Brooklyn, NY
(718) 230-3119
This Carroll Gardens bakery has recently gotten a lot of attention for its
whoopie pies, and rightfully so.  Pastry chef Emily Isaacs resume includes Esca, Union Square Cafe, and Picholine.  Isaacs’ whoopie pie looks a little like a pudgy Oreo —  a classic cream filling sandwiched between two chocolatey cookies.

Whole Foods Market
4 Union Square South (btwn. B’way & University Pl.)
(212) 673-5388
Nothing beats fresh-baked sweets, but it’s always good to have an emergency stash in your apartment for sugar cravings.  If you can’t find a baker, head to the refrigerator section for Whole Foods’  whoopie pies. Their flavors include chocolate, vanilla, and chocolate chip, each with a thick buttercream filling. 



  1. Agreed! One Girl Cookies is excellent. Any new finds do send them my way.

  2. I’m on it! Thanks for the tip.

  3. I never was a big whoopie pie fan, but Wannahavacookie’s Red Velvet with raspberry icing ones won me over! Marisa also makes a mean Snickerdoodle! Yummmmmm!

  4. i loved this post. i am a big whoopie pie fan, and have been to nearly all the places that you have mentioned and tried their pies, and the ones i have not yet visited (especially that bakery on vanderbilt) is now on my list to check out. of the pies mentioned, i think that my personal favorite is from one girl cookies — quite tasty, and just the right size and proportion of middle and outside.

  5. i am definitely a big whoopie pie fan, and i think i have tried all of the ones on your list except for joyce bakeshop and the wannahaveacookie site so i might just have to go by those places. i had never even heard of those two bakeries though i haven’t been to the flea in a while. and of the group i know, i think that i like one girl cookies the best — not too big and not too small and pretty classic. thanks for the fun post.

  6. You MUST try the pumpkin Whoopie Pie at Tazza in Brooklyn Heights… AMAZING.

Leave a Reply to Joy Birky Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *