166 S. 4th Street,
Phone: (347) 529-6090
Pies n Thighs’ fried chicken is so good you might forget the first part of this Southern joint’s name. Keep your eye on the ball because these are some of the best pies in the city. Their menu features a flurry of options, including Banana Cream, Key Lime, Choco Peanut Butter Crunch, Sour Cherry, Smores, and Apple, all available whole or by the slice. Come autumn, we’re nibbling at their Apple Pie, which can be warmed with Grafton Cheddar Cheese for an dollar (no brainer!) It’s not unusual to find one or two special seasonal pies on the menu as well. Right about now, they’re baking up a Concord Grape Pie (my favorite) with a Pepper Pastry Crust. Yum.